New Features
Legal Research: The Topic Tool and ISDS Guidebook
- Our Guidebook written by the IAReporter team gives a succinct overview of jurisprudence on key topics;
- The Topic Tool indexes our 15+ years of reporting on decisions, awards and rulings, allowing users to research how more than 3000 legal and valuation topics have been handled by arbirators and courts;
- The Topic Tool is updated on an ongoing basis to provide a broad and up-to-the-minute overview of the case law (including many otherwise non-public decisions);
- Additional filters allow users to research a topic only in relation to a particular arbitrator, state, treaty, rules, etc.;
- In 2024, we added an “industry” filter, so that users can research case law concepts as they have been applied in a chosen sector (e.g. mining, oil & gas, etc.)
Watch this short video for an overview of the Topic Tool and ISDS Guidebook:
Video transcript: Topic Tool and ISDS Guidebook
- Hello, I’m Luke Peterson, the publisher of IAReporter, and today I’m very excited to announce the launch of two new website features, our topic tool and our ISDS guidebook.
- Because our database contains 15 years of reporting on international investment law, sometimes its sheer size makes it difficult to research a particular legal concept.
- For example, if you were to do a keyword search for something like, you’d get more than 500 reports from our archive.
- Each report can be more than 3, 4,000 words long, so you could easily spend all day skimming through a million words in order to try to piece together a picture of how a particular issue like corruption has been handled by international tribunals.
- Well, now we have an amazing research shortcut. Our team led by Damien Charlotin, Lisa Bohmer and Jarrod Hepburn, painstakingly reviewed and indexed 15 years of specialized reporting and developed user facing tools that now allow you to research more than 2500 legal and valuation topics.
- So whether you’re writing a brief, a decision or an academic article, you can easily learn how a particular topic has been addressed in the jurisprudence.
- So let’s jump into our website and take a closer look, first at the topic tool. So I’m going to look for a particular case, and the way to do that is anybody familiar with our website will know is to go to the case profiles and search for a particular party name here.
- Searching for Spentex will bring up the Spentex versus Uzbekistan case. Now we’re looking at the case profile for that case and what I want to do is pull up the summary of the key decision located here.
- So now we’ve got the discussion of the December 2016 award in this case. And it’s a very long report as many of ours are because they give a detailed account of the of all of the significant holdings and reasoning in a particular award or decision.
- The reports are broken up in very subheadings which describe what what’s discussed in a particular section of the article. And as you may notice now beside each of these subheadings, you see a little red notation which says explore topics.
- Now if I click on that, it’s going to unfold and give you a list of the key topics that arise in this particular section of our report.
- You’ve got the general topic of jurisdiction and a missability and more specific topics like legality of investment, corruption, proof and evidence and red flags indicative of corruption.
- So I’m going to click on red flags and that will take us over to our new topic tool. And now we’re in the topic tool.
- And you’ll see here a definition, which is a definition of corruption written by a reporter analysts. So we’re using the general state of play in relation to this topic and just below the definition are 24 results, all of which pertain to the specific issue of red flags.
- So each of these results is a section from our prior reporting on a particular award or decision or judicial development related to red flags.
- date and you can click on any of these to reveal the relevant discussion on the topic of red flags. And so you can read that discussion, get up to speed on what was discussed on this particular topic in this particular case.
- And let’s say you want to read for wider context, the full report on the entire case. You can do that by clicking on the read full analysis here.
- And maybe you want to just get the original source document be it a decision award or what have you if it is available on our website, you can find it by clicking few source document.
- So you can refold in a result by clicking on the headline. And another useful thing to know is if you go up to this box that says unfold results, you can click on that and it will unfold all of your results.
- This is particularly helpful if you like to use control F to search for a particular keyword that maybe you’re looking for to see if it came up in any of our discussions.
- So if you’re looking for a particular discussion of a topic, you can unfold everything and then do that easily. And then if you want to refold the results, just click here.
- So this is an indication of the red flags results. Another thing you can do with them is to go to our set of filters, which can be applied to whittle down your research.
- So we have three filters that are visible by default pertaining to arbitrator state and the treaty clicking on the more filters button will reveal all nine filters that are available.
- So if we’re to select, let’s say arbitrator and look for the red flags cases, case discussions that involve Brigitte Stern, there are six of them.
- So clicking on her name will refresh the results down here and you will see just six results. If you want to remove the filter, you just click on the X here.
- and you can do that. You can reset the entire tool so that your topical research and the red flags is deleted.
- So we just click on this button that says clear all. And then we have the ability to just browse and navigate through our so called topic tree, which is located here on the left hand side, just below a search bar, which is also another way that you can kind of look for particular topics in the topic
- tool. But let’s focus on the top of the list. So you can unfold the entire tree by clicking on this button and doing so will give you a very clear impression of just how enormous the topic tool is and the number of topics that are contained there in.
- So scrolling down through this, you see all kinds of topics and subtopics and clicking on any of them, let’s say conflict of laws, 86 results.
- Once again, bring up the relevant discussions from our prior reports about this particular issue, conflict of laws. Another thing you can do is because these results are typically drawn from our reports about decisions or awards so that the jurisprudence.
- But let’s say you want to focus your research query even a little bit more broadly and pull in anything that is a party position on a topic of interest to you.
- Well, in rare circumstances, I report a right about party pleadings. These are not generally public in these cases, but from time to time they are and from time to time we’ve written summaries and digested party pleadings.
- So if you want to include those in your search results, what you do is you come up here just below the filter box.
- There’s a line that says your research has generated 83 results drawn from our previous reporting on decisions to also display pleadings, click here.
- Doing so will refresh the search and you can see that the number of results has gone from 83 to 86.
- And so if we go down, you can find those particular extracts that deal with party positions because they will be notated in gray.
- It will say something like as it does here, non-disputing parties pleading. So it’s easy to identify which of these extracts actually are party related.
- So this is a brief overview of the topic tool. And the other thing that I wanted to show you today very briefly is our ISDS guidebook, which is also interlinked with the topic tool.
- And you can get to the guidebook for indeed the topic tool by going over in the right hand portion of our menu and selecting either of them.
- But I’m going to choose the guidebook now. And what you’ll see is as the name suggests is a guidebook that’s been written and entirely by I a reporter’s expert team and which gives you a summary of the state of international investment law in relation to various topics.
- So we have a table of contents, which is over here in the form of a tree, which you can unfold.
- And you can kind of get a flavor of the types of issues that are discussed in the guidebook. So let’s take advance on costs.
- And that pulls up a short three paragraph overview of the how this issue has been dealt with in the cases.
- And key tests or concepts that arise, such as allocation of costs. And as I mentioned, the guidebook is very much interlinked with the topic tool.
- So clicking on any of these red linked items, such as allocation, will take you over to the topic tool and show you the relevant discussions in our database on this particular subtopic of allocation of costs.
- And here there are eight results, any of which you could click on and read up on read the full analysis of the case if you want, etc.
- So the guidebook is an excellent tool. I’m just going to go back to the guidebook here. The guidebook is a really excellent tool for both newcomers and beginners to kind of learn about different areas of international investment law.
- And also for more experienced practitioners or users of our website who just want to refresh their memory about the current state of play of an issue that they may not have dealt with for a year or more or many years.
- And so the guidebook allows you to do that and just jump in and get a high level overview. And then drill into any particular issues, go into the topic tool and see all of the discussion that we have in our database about that particular topic.
- So we’re going to be updating the guidebook and the topic tool on a rolling basis from now on. So we do reporting every day as our users will know.
- And so we will be updating both of these tools so that they were made very current and provide you an unparalleled window into what’s happening in this particular area of international investment law.
- And we’re also going to be expanding a little bit more our focus day to day so that we encompass more public international law and international commercial arbitration decisions and awards and judgments when they touch upon topics of interest so that our topic tool and our guidebook will be of the most
- value. to our users. But of course we may have overlooked certain things and putting together the topic tool. And if you see any particular case or citation that’s not present in the topic tool.
- By all means, please reach out to us. You can contact us at editor at iu reporter.com and we’ll be happy to have any feedback from you on these new tools.
- Thanks very much for your time.
Newly-enhanced Arbitrator Profiles
- Insight into under-the-radar ISDS appointments not recorded elsewhere;
- Ability to sort appointments by year, type and status;
- Mapping of overlaps and relationships with other arbitrators;
- Visual analytics; and
- Custom news-feed so you can follow news about specific arbitrators.
Watch this short video for an overview of the Arbitrator Profiles:
Video transcript: Arbitrator Profiles
Hello and welcome to the short tutorial about our newly enhanced arbitrator profiles feature. These profiles offer detailed information about the caseloads of more than 200 of the most active arbitrators in investor state arbitration. You can access the arbitrator profile’s landing page by clicking here on the main menu of our website.
Here you’ll find an alphabetical list of all arbitrators for whom we have a profile. Generally, we create a profile once an individual has appeared in at least three investor state cases. If you click on the name of any individual, you’ll be taken through to that person’s particular profile.
So let’s try one here, Bruno Zimo. Also, when reading any of our reports on our website, you can also click on an arbitrator’s name. If they have a profile, you’ll be redirected there.
The first notable feature you’ll find on any profile is a list of cases where the arbitrator has sat or is currently sitting. A crucial thing to know about our arbitrator profiles is that they often include ISDS cases that do not appear anywhere else in the public domain. That’s because I reporter are an investigative reporting service, and we routinely uncovered cases, or older cases, that are otherwise under the radar.
For instance, if you scroll through the list of cases on Mr. Zimmer’s profile, you’ll see the Acreum versus Egypt case, which is not currently reported anywhere else. Obviously, the inclusion of such otherwise unreported cases is particularly crucial, if you’re performing due diligence research, or undertaking a conflict check. You can sort the list of cases on an arbitrator profile, like clicking on the arrows here, if you want to click by type of appointment, sorting by respondent appointments, followed by parties, co arbitrators, and appointing authority.
Or the status of cases, if you want to see all the concluded cases, they’re sorted here and below that, depending cases. Clicking on any of these case names will take you to a separate profile page for that case. In fact, in a separate video, we’ll introduce you to our case profiles feature, and how it can revolutionize your research on our website.
But for now, let’s continue to look at the other features of the arbitrator profiles. To facilitate due diligence, we also have, on the right hand column, blated arbitrator’s tool. This tool tells you how frequently the arbitrator has overlapped with other arbitrators in investor state cases. with the number indicated brackets after the name.
Now, this may not mean that the arbitrator sat together at the same time, but it does indicate that they were involved in a common case somehow. Most often, these will be instances where the arbitrator set together on a tribunal. But you’ll also have instances where one of them sat on a tribunal, and the other individual was involved in a different phase of the case. perhaps as a member of an annulment committee.
Let’s click on an example here. If we choose Donald McRae, this will bring up three cases where Mr. Zimma and Mr. McRae were involved as adjudicators. And you can click through to see the details about any of those cases if you want.
Now, bear in mind that when you use this related arbitrator’s tool, it takes you away from a specific arbitrator profile and brings you over to another part of our website, where all ISD is case data. is housed. This case profile section, which you see highlighted here, offers a much broader set of data and research tools. And as we mentioned earlier, you can learn all about the case files by watching our case profiles, and advanced research techniques, videos.
For now, though, let’s briefly jump back to Mr. Zimma’s profile just to finish our tour of our arbitrator profiles. So apart from the list of cases and the related arbitrator’s tool, if we scroll down, you’ll see that each profile also offers a series of analytics, which give a visual overview of the timing and type of an arbitrator’s appointment. And finally, scrolling further down, every profile has a custom news feed, which is curated, so it is to give you easy access to all I reporter articles that discuss this particular arbitrator’s caseload.
This is an excellent way to track the work of specific arbitrators. So thanks for watching. Please check out our separate videos on the case profiles and the advanced research techniques.
Case Profiles
Our Case Profiles give a snapshot of key data for more than 2400 ISDS cases, including
- Tribunal composition (incl. how each arbitrator was appointed);
- Basic data (treaty, rules, status);
- Counsel of record;
- One-click access to key decisions and IAReporter summaries;
- Custom news-feed of IAReporter reporting and analysis on each case.
Watch this short video for an overview of the Case Profiles:
Video transcript: Case Profiles
And welcome to this video tutorial for our new case profiles feature. On our main landing page, which can be accessed by clicking the case profiles link here on our homepage, you’ll see a list of every case in our database. You can scroll down, browse the list if you like, or you can sort it, using these arrows, the top of each column.
You can sort it by alphabetical names. type, which includes contract, treaty, or domestic investment law, the year of filing, or the status, indicating whether the arbitration is pending or concluded, and whether a set aside or annulment phase is pending or concluded. If you click on a case name, that will take you to that cases profile page. In a moment, we’ll walk you through the key features of a typical profile page.
But before we do that, we also wanted to point out that many of our articles contain links, which refer you to particular case profiles. For instance, check out this article. In this field right here, right after the date and the name of the author, there’s an indication of which case this article is primarily about.
If you click on that link, it will take you through to the case profile for this particular case. We’re just gonna back out, though, and show you a different example of a case profile. Which we have preloaded here.
This is for the Mecula versus Romania. Case, the first for two cases between those parties. So, on the left, you’ll see some key data, including your filing, the status of the case, which indicates that the annulment has concluded.
Names of the parties, the rules, the treaty, the relevant VIT, and over on the right hand side, for those cases where the award or annulment decision are public, you can find downloadable copies of those documents in this box, under major development. Conveniently, we also signpost, I.E. reporter summary and analysis of those decisions in the recommended reading box. To scroll down further on the right, you’ll see the identity of counsel for claimant and the respondent.
It’s important to emphasize that we list all counsel who are involved in the case, even if they were not involved for the entirety of the case. This inclusive approach ensures that you can perform more effective due diligence and conflict checking. Over on the left, you’ll see the identity of the arbitrators, as well as the names of any former members of the tribunal.
And below that, you’ll see the names of the ad hoc committee members for those cases that operated in the IXID rules and which had an annulment phase. Another key feature of our case profiles is the custom news feed that allows you to see at a glance all of the eye report or stories that discuss this particular case. This is a curated news feed, so we’ve only included the important report, so you won’t have to wade through dozens and dozens of links, which might only mention a case peripherally.
One final thing to stress, if we scroll back up, is that all of the red highlighted names and data points on these case profiles can be clicked, and this will lead you to a listing of all other cases of this type. So, for example, if you click on any of the arbitrator names, that will take you to their arbitrator profile, if they have one on our website. And if you click on other types of data, for example, councils, names, which are over here, say, King and Spalding, that would bring you to a list of all new cases where they acted as counsel to acclaim it.
So, hopefully, this has given you some basic overview of our case profiles feature. However, if you scroll back to the main landing page, or just click here, you’ll see that there is a search tool located just here, not to be confused with the broader search engine, which is used for all of our articles and reports on our website. And you’ll also see that there are a series of filtering tools for these case profiles.
In a separate video on advanced research techniques, we’ll walk you through some of the things that you can do with this special search tool and these filtering tools. Thanks for watching.
Due diligence, conflict checking and advanced research
Powerful filter and search tools allow you to use the our dataset of 2400+ ISDS cases (many of them not reported elsewhere), in order to
- Find cases involving specific parties, arbitrators or law firms;
- Explore relationships between parties, arbitrators and law firms;
- Investigate all known uses of a specific treaty or set of arbitral rules; and
- Find and sort cases based on status (pending/concluded) or year of filing.
Watch a short video on advanced research techniques:
Video transcript: Advanced research techniques
Hello and welcome to this instructional video showing you how to conduct advanced research using our case profiles data set. We’ll show you a new search engine for searching case data. As well as a series of filtering tools to extract greater value from our entire data set.
Whether you’re doing due diligence on a party, or an arbitrator, checking for potential conflict, or otherwise doing research in the field of investor state arbitration, IA reporters data sets the industry standard, because it’s the broadest ISDS data set in the world. The reason that our data set is so broad is because we’re an investigative reporting service that is constantly uncovering cases or arbitrator appointments that are otherwise taking place without publicity. So while there are many websites that collect information that’s pulled from public domain sources, like the exit website, or court documents, ours is constantly pulling from under the radar sources.
In order to give you a wider view of what is actually happening in the sometimes opaque world of investor state arbitration. So how can you put all this data to work for you? Well, first, from our homepage, let’s navigate over to our profiles section of our website, which is located here in the main menu.
Now, the first thing to stress is that our website now has two search tools. There’s our familiar search tool sitting at the top of the site, and you should use this particular tool if you’re looking to search through our entire archive of reporting an analysis. So if you want to search for a particular keyword, or maybe a legal concept, such as res judicata, this is the place.
However, due to the size of our archive of news and analysis reports, you may get a lot of results. And what if you’re just trying to research one particular case? Well, that’s where the new cases search tool comes in, and it’s located over here.
And it will only be visible from the case profiles main page. It allows you to search within our case’s data set only, rather than within the entire archive of news and analysis articles on our site. So, if you enter the name of a particular investor, let’s say, Cellini, in this search tool, you’ll find that Cellini has been involved in six ISTS cases, each of which is listed here.
If you click on, let’s say, the Salini versus Morocco case, you’ll land on the case profile for that particular case, where you’ll find key data about the case, including its status, as well as click links to any decisions. I report her summary of those decisions, and a custom news feed, which gives you the most important reporting. Now, if we go back to our main case profiles page, you can see that the case’s search tool lets you cut through an entire forest of reporting and cases and get to exactly the case or cases that you’re looking for.
But that’s just the first useful feature that we want to show you. Just underneath this search tool are a series of powerful filtering tools. located here. that allow you to whittle our data down. and to draw connections between different data points. So you can look for cases under a particular set of arbitrary rules, which will be here, particular treaty, or a party.
You just go to the relevant filtering tool. Let’s go to the treaty tool. And click.
And you can scroll down through all the various options. Or just start typing the name of what you’re looking for. If you’re interested in the U.S. Ecuador BIT, just start typing Ecuador.
And up comes a list of all cases arising under different Ecuadorian BITs. including the U.S. Ecuador bit, which has been used in 17 cases. in our data set. If you click on this box, those 17 cases will appear here on the right hand side. And you can click on any of those to see the case profile and more information about that particular case.
But maybe you’re more interested to know which arbitrators have the most experience with the U.S. Ecuador Treaty. Well, you can continue to filter within your results. Just scroll down to the arbitrator’s filtering tool, located here, and click, and you’ll see a list of arbitrators with a number beside their name.
That number indicates how many times they have arbitrated under this particular treaty. So let’s pick Brigitte’s turn, and up will come a list of her five cases under the U.S. Ecuador B.I.T. You can keep filtering if you want. Maybe you want to know which council for claimant, or for respondent, were involved in those five cases.
Here it’s important to know that we have two separate tools, one for claimant counsel, here, and just below it, one for respondent counsel. So you’ll want to check both of those, which you can do, and zero in on any relationships of interest. As you’re probably starting to appreciate, when you’re working with the broadest set of ISTS data, you can identify relationships that might not be apparent based on more limited public sources.
Whenever you finish your filtering inquiry, you can reset the filters by clicking here on the clear all button. And… you will see all cases are now appearing, again. All 1,400 cases in our data set.
So let’s try a new research question. Maybe you want to do research on a particular law firm and see which arbitrators they’re most comparing in front of. The place to look, again, is in our claimant council and our responding council filters.
So let’s go down. If you type in fresh fields in the Claimant Council filter, and then click the box to see the 89 results, which will pop up here. These are the 89 results.
And then scroll down to another filter. Let’s go to the arbitrator filter. and filter through these 89 cases where fresh fields have been canceled to claim it. To see which arbitrators have appeared most frequently, and here’s the list, the number, and brackets.
So let’s select Gabrielle Kalfman Kohler. There are nine cases, and they’re listed here. Where Fresh Fields acted as council for the claimant, and where she sat as an arbitrator.
Or possibly as an annulment committee member. Now, it’s important to stress that our data set identifies all of the known relationships. But Miss Calvin Kohler may not have been appointed by fresh fields in those nine cases.
So you shouldn’t presume causal relationships here. Instead, you’ll want to click through and view each of these cases and research further to see how the appointments were made. Once you’ve investigated Field’s cases as claimant council, and then browse to see which arbitrators appear most frequently, you can do the same in relation to the respondent council work.
But first, you have to clear out your previous filter job by clicking here. And then you’ll scroll down to the respondent council tool. And start a new filtering job.
As you’re starting to see, the case profile’s data set is a very powerful data set that allows you to identify the activity and relationship of parties, even parent companies, which are located here. Council appointing authorities, treaties, arbitrators, year of filing, claimants, respondent, filtering by case status as possible. And we’re constantly improving our data set, fixing small mistakes, and adding new data that comes to our attention.
So, for this reason, we encourage you to always cross check data in our data set before you rely on it in a litigation context. And if you have questions or data to share, please reach out to us by emailing editor at IA reporter.com. Thanks for watching.